Scientific arguments against carbon dating

Rated 4.28/5 based on 788 customer reviews

Long-age proponents will dismiss this sort of evidence for a young age of the earth by arguing that the assumptions about the past do not apply in these cases.In other words, age is not really a matter of scientific observation but an argument about our assumptions about the unobserved past.Such is the nature of science, especially historical science, because we cannot do experiments on past events (see “It’s not science”).Science is based on observation, and the only reliable means of telling the age of anything is by the testimony of a reliable witness who observed the events.

scientific arguments against carbon dating-23

scientific arguments against carbon dating-52

So, we have a “clock” which starts ticking the moment something dies.Carbon has unique properties that are essential for life on Earth.Familiar to us as the black substance in charred wood, as diamonds, and the graphite in “lead” pencils, carbon comes in several forms, or isotopes.If the calculated result gives an acceptable age, the investigators publish it.Examples of ages listed here are also obtained by applying the same principle of uniformitarianism.

Leave a Reply